Butter Consignment in Brooklyn

In With the Old

As luxury prices soar, fashion lovers flock to consignment shops.

March 2008

When Janet Clarke, a successful businesswoman with a formidable retail habit, purchased a $3,000 Escada jacket in Schiaparelli pink leather last year, she did so not with the flush of excitement that certain expensive luxury purchases elicit, but with a cool, calculated eye toward the piece’s potential resale value. “I wore it once,” Clarke says on a recent winter afternoon, gesturing toward the item in question hanging on a rack—an $895 price tag dangling from one butter-soft arm—at Michael’s, a women’s consignment shop on Manhattan’s Upper East Side where Clarke is a regular. “If somebody goes for it, I’ll get about $450,” she adds, smiling proudly. “I can afford to shop anywhere, but consignment has the best bargains these days, and the stuff is so good now. I shop and I consign. It’s great to know that if you make a mistake, you won’t lose all your money.”

The shoe display at Ina on Thompson Street, in Manhattan

What the ladies who lunch have known for years—that a trim bouclé Chanel suit or an eye-popping Pucci caftan can each fetch hundreds of dollars at the neighborhood resale store, where that Yves Saint Laurent Mombasa bag you coveted a few years back can be nabbed for a quarter of its original price—has trickled down to the fashion-forward masses. Consignment shopping is not only a red-hot shopping option, but now blatantly out in the open as wealthy and cash-strapped fashionistas alike descend unabashed on resale boutiques from Aspen to L.A. with armfuls of near mint-condition clothes. They’re eager to purge closets of gently used designer duds and keen to pick up a check for later purchases. As Laura Fluhr, the longtime owner of Michael’s, puts it, “We’re not the dirty little store on the side street anymore.”

Store owners who consider themselves voyeurs—observing people’s often quirky, deeply personal shopping habits—suggest that the ever increasing prices of luxury goods, particularly in the handbag and high-heel departments, have sparked a surge in consignment shopping. Environmentalism, owners say, may also be a factor. While $110 organic cotton T-shirts help reduce fashion’s carbon footprint, so, too, can recycling preworn Prada cardigans.

According to Christos Garkinos, co-owner, with Cameron Silver, of Decadestwo, a designer consignment store on L.A.’s Melrose Avenue, the game of shopping, consignment style, has two players: those wealthy enough to buy anything yet eager for the thrill of a great find, and those desperate for a trend item but unable to afford it at full price. “Of the women with money, there are three types of consignment shoppers,” explains Garkinos. “There’s the one who will totally wear anything, who lives for the latest It thing in fashion. There’s the…folks who treat fashion as art and collect. They may overshop, but they overshop for a reason. They’re really into Marni, for instance, as a way to amass a collection. And then there are the people who will buy the same pair of shoes…in three different colors, and will never wear them. And that’s some sort of OCD going on there.” Garkinos pauses. “We tend to be a healthy outlet for some addictive personalities.”

Comments

Post a Comment

Give a gift

Enter for a chance to win a stunning Tous necklace, worth $1,272.

Our editors pick the very best sunglasses, flat sandals, watches, lingerie and more.

Our up-to-date archive of all W's exclusive fashion and celebrity videos.

W Newsletter

Sign up to receive the latest on fashion, art and style delivered to your email inbox.

Fashion Portfolios

Peasant blouses, patterned layers and sheerness everywhere, all under headdresses that are a force of nature. Photographed by Mario Sorrenti.

Brit it-girls Daisy Lowe and Peaches Geldof channel their inner juvenile delinquents. Photographed by Steven Meisel.

In the leafy Eden of Dominica, dresses and skirts have the vivid quality of tropical flowers and plants. Photographed by Juergen Teller.

Linda Evangelista shows us she's still untouchable. Photographed by Steven Klein.
Hammam

Kate Moss gets all steamed up at a Turkish bathhouse. Photographed by Mert Alas and Marcus Piggott.

The architecture, seafront and boats of Istanbul mirror the bold, geometric shapes of cocktail and evening looks.
Champion

Christy Turlington works the warrior-goddess side of Greco-Roman influence. Photographed by Michael Thompson.
Summer Camp

Sixteen of the industry's hottest new designers hit Miami for some fun in the sun. Photographed by Bruce Weber.

W Blogs

W Newsletter

Sign up to receive the latest on fashion, art and style delivered to your email inbox.

Christy Turlington Burns

Champion

One good classic deserves another. Christy Turlington Burns works the warrior-goddess side of Greco-Roman influence. Photographed by Michael Thompson.

W Blogs

Brad Pitt and Angelina Jolie

Domestic Bliss

The Steven Klein shoot that started it all: Mr. and Mrs. Smith costars Brad Pitt and Angelina Jolie play house in Palm Springs. (July 2005)