Celebrities, they receive terrible, horrible, totally inexplicable gifts during the holidays, too! From an empty gerbil cage (the critter had escaped before Christmas morning) to bewildering contact lens solution (the recipient doesn’t wear them), find out which Hollywood A-listers from George Clooney to Elle Fanning suffered the most while having to maintain their holiday cheer face. As in life, though, within the worst presents often hide the best (see: Andrew Garfield)—and sometimes, it’s hard to decipher if something is in fact the best or the worst idea. Plus, there are the lucky few famous people who have received unambiguously life-affirming great gifts. Let’s indulge them a little.